New freight: yey or nay?

15 years ago

+ the new 1 is like a tutorial in bad map design. where as cp_freight was actually a very high quality map which had a few bugs. freight_final just feels Frankenstein’s monster. It used to be human; but it has died, been roughly sewn back together, then injected with life by valve publishing it.

can someone do a freight_pro with just bugfixes on it. there are good improvements made in final but the vast majority are bad. if we took out the bad we would be left with freight but with a slightly altered sniper window on last and a train light at middle.

edit: i sound like i am raging at the map maker about final. but really am just proclaiming my undieing love for cp_freight and how depressed i am he has taken it away from me

Last edited by Sketch, 15 years ago

Malibu Stacey™

Sir.

15 years ago

If it’s choice between cp_freight or cp_freight_final1 then I’d always pick cp_freight_final1.

However there are better maps available. Maybe need a MNM on this to get people to see how much better it is than the original version (so many bug fixes & yet people still want the old one). It seemed to work well for cp_yukon_final this week so hopefully it’d do the same for cp_freight_final1 too.

Koeitje

AUTOBOTS

15 years ago

The old freight needed 3 fixes:
– Spawn times
– Closed spawn @ 2nd
– Maybe third entrance into second point from bottom left. Not nearly such a must as the first two fixes.

baerbel

trick17
trick17

15 years ago

Quoted from Koeitje

The old freight needed 3 fixes:
– Spawn times
– Closed spawn @ 2nd
– Maybe third entrance into second point from bottom left. Not nearly such a must as the first two fixes.

isnt that whats fixed in final1?

Koeitje

AUTOBOTS

15 years ago

Quoted from baerbel

[…]

isnt that whats fixed in final1?

Yes. But with extra added bullshit @ the 2nd point.

15 years ago

its a terrible map. <.<

TucE

tR67
KUKKO!

15 years ago

YEY

Stew

15 years ago

nay

Black_Bob

[DA]

15 years ago

yay been playing it a fair bit recently and think its a good map :)

King Pave

15 years ago

YEYEYEYEYEYEYEYEY

Last edited by King Pave, 15 years ago

TRanky

10B\'s

14 years ago

I try the new freigth in 6on6 and is really better than freight_long_respawn_time

Last edited by TRanky, 14 years ago

Jakko

14 years ago

Thery are tbh “practically” the same only big difference is in cp2, Witch ever one goes on the roster theres gonna be haters that want the other one, I just think the official freight will be the better one, seems more work has gone into it.

Ripple